Crude Oil in This Environment: Should You Speculate?
*Disclaimer these posts are for educational and/or entertainment purposes only. If you want more warnings and disclaimers check every footer on every page, or click here, it sends you to the same disclaimer if you're too lazy to hit [end] on your keyboard. These posts are not advice, trades you do are of your own, if we hint to try something, it's to test on a demo or at your own risk, we never guarantee profitability.*
Introduction
Crude oil has always been one of those markets where the outside world leaks directly into price. You don’t need to watch it long to realize it reacts to far more than supply and demand on paper. Shipping disruptions, geopolitical tension, refinery capacity, sanctions, production cuts — all of it eventually shows up somewhere in the chart.
What I question is the rationality of the move. I usually bank on irrational dislocated moves as the norm, as it's price discovery after all.
People sometimes treat oil like any other commodity future, but the reality is it sits at the center of a massive global system. Transportation, manufacturing, energy costs, inflation signals — when oil moves, it rarely moves alone. That’s why periods of uncertainty often produce the most interesting environments for speculation.
Oil Doesn't Move in Isolation
Unlike many markets that mostly react to financial flows, crude oil reacts to physical constraints. Oil has to be drilled, transported, refined, and distributed before it becomes the fuel people actually use.
Just because a tanker arrives somewhere doesn’t mean gasoline magically appears at the pump the next morning. Refining capacity, processing time, logistics, and storage all create delays. Those delays create uncertainty, and markets hate uncertainty.
The Iran conflict vs USA is a prime example. The strait is a focal point of pain, it translates into the price as an aberration.
That uncertainty is exactly what gets priced in.
The irrational valuation as I stated earlier is price discovery at its finest form.
One counterparty, experiences pain while the other experiences a windfall.
Volatility Follows Uncertainty
When the world becomes unstable, oil tends to react quickly. Traders start pricing scenarios: supply interruptions, shipping delays, sanctions, production adjustments, demand shocks.
This is where volatility starts expanding.
Volatility — or Vol, as traders shorten it — isn’t just random movement. It’s the market adjusting to information that isn’t fully known yet. The more uncertain the environment becomes, the more violently price can move while participants attempt to reprice risk.
That environment naturally attracts speculation.
The speculation can be in various forms, there are the hedgers/refiners/producers who collateralized their commodity /CL with futures contracts against their black gold. Demand destruction = price collapse. Hedged? Contract holder is good. The inverse is the same, high demand? Your underlying wins, you cover your short insurance, sell your commodity at the market above where you usually do.
Futures sold against the crude can be taken short by a tiny speculator, maybe some futures trader in an apartment that has an account big enough to short the contract, or a former pit trader that runs his own book personally.
Whatever the speculative form, we're all in the same liquid pool of black gold.
Humans vs Machines
Humans sometimes catch fortunate moves in volatile markets. A trader sees a headline, reacts quickly, and catches a spike or a collapse.
But systematic operators usually dominate environments like this.
Algorithms don’t hesitate. They don’t stop to rethink the signal, they don’t get distracted, and they don’t miss the trade because they were second-guessing themselves for five seconds. If a condition triggers, the system executes.
That speed advantage matters when volatility expands.
In my case, I'm systematic first, emotional never. I learned from my early days I'm incapable of trading via discretion. Thus I adapted overtime along with advancements in tech to settle in Systematic/Automated trading. Not discretionary and not HFT (High Frequency Trading), but the sweet spot for my personal situation.
Some probably refuse automation, Maybe semi-automation is for you.
Just like me, I refuse to get on the EV bandwagon, and love driving a manual transmission. Ironic right? Manual driver, Automated trader, make that make sense.
Anyways, I'm not pushing automation on you the speculator, but it's something to consider, as edges vanish, Machine Learning (ML) programs farm data on discretionary tendencies, and developers create code that hunt for your discretion.
These are the predatory algorithms, you may not believe it but this is true.
Regardless, this is a conversation for another time.
My Perspective
In my case, I do speculate in environments like this.
Not because oil is guaranteed to move in a predictable way — it isn’t — but because uncertainty creates opportunity. Markets that are completely calm rarely produce meaningful moves.
That said, speculation without preparation is just gambling. You're better off flipping a non loaded coin and executing your strategy this way, at least you're prepared with a quarter right?
I’ve removed most of the emotional component by structuring trades around margin availability and automation. Code handles the execution, and margin is sized so that individual trades don’t threaten the system as a whole.
I always tell myself, even in my code I
//abstract away emotion
As a comment above that doesn't execute, but every time I patch or review my work, the reminder is there.
Did I slightly code emotion by commenting that in? Maybe, but it doesn't run now does it?
I still reserve the right to intervene if something breaks or the code does something unexpected. But most of the time the system simply does what it was designed to do. High Vol days, IEA, NFP, CPI, FOMC, I'm there as a manual circuit breaker just incase.
Final Thoughts
None of this is meant as encouragement for anyone to speculate in crude oil simply because I do. This is just how I look at the market based on experience.
I see volatility as opportunity and it's reflected in price, I leverage systems and automation to attempt to harness that vol better than most manual speculators.
Oil sits at the intersection of geopolitics, logistics, and energy demand. When that system becomes unstable, price tends to reflect it quickly.
Some traders avoid that environment entirely.
Others see it as an opportunity, sometimes once in a lifetime.
In closing
If you find these journal entries helpful, please consider subscribing here.
~Asymmetric_Vol
Entries of Interest
Asymmetric_Vol
Asymmetric_Vol